I usually like Laura Miller's taste in books. But maybe she should take a break from reviewing.
Honestly the thing that bothered me the most in this piece was the part about all the community going "read my book" and not looking for something to read. Because I can't imagine writing more than, say, Seanan McGuire, so maybe three books a year. And I read way more than that! Possibly 20x as many! Where else am I going to find out about what to read? Please, suggest away!